Cat GIF
 about
 contact
 projects
 rambles

Currently


"Say No To Sports."

Listening to


About

welcome to sanchit.cc
This is my little corner on the Internet with random stuff vaguely relating to me

Quick Facts

About the site

Contact

Projects

Blog

Hello, Free Will and Human Behavioural Biology(an unstructured collection of random ideas with no good conclusion)


MIT opencourseware on the topic | Sabrina hofstetter's video John Horgan’s Blog | An edeucated view on quantum entanglement argument against free will

Introduction

Does free will exist? A rabbit hole I went down and studied on exclusively for about a week and a half. All of the information is factual (for as far as I could verify), and I have given out some of the sources and further readings.


Facets of the Discussion

1. The Biological Determinism of Our Actions

A significant portion of our actions can be attributed to our biological makeup.
For example:

This level of predictability makes it difficult to believe in a form of free will that is truly independent of biology. But that is not all — our nurture can explain the few remaining percentage of "autonomous" actions that couldn’t have been foreseen by just knowing our biological heritage. I won't go into this facet because I don't know enough about it to form an opinion, and the evidence for biological influence was strong enough.

But what about the other side of the coin? Surely the believers must have a pretty strong counterpoint too, right?


Arguments for Free Will

  1. Compatibilism: This philosophical stance argues that free will can coexist with the deterministic laws of nature. Even if our actions are influenced by biology and environment, we can still exercise a form of choice within these constraints.
  2. Conscious Decision-Making: Supporters of free will argue that the conscious process of deliberation and choice demonstrates a form of autonomy.
  3. Quantum Entanglement: I don't understand this idea well enough, but from what I could infer, there are many physical limitations for it to exist. Refer to this video for context, or this could be just confirmation bias.

Supporting Resources:


Arguments Against Free Will

  1. Deterministic Nature of the Brain: The brain operates through a complex web of neural activity. These processes are driven by biology and past experiences rather than any conscious “self” making independent decisions.
  2. Sabine Hossenfelder’s Analysis: Sabine Hossenfelder’s discussions on free will provide a scientific foundation for the deterministic view, emphasizing that the laws of physics govern all processes in the brain.

These arguments make it difficult to support the idea that free will exists in any meaningful sense.


My Confusions

Based on my research and reflection, I'm inclined to believe that that free will does not exist as it dosen't have much evidence in it's support.

The massive Implications of This naive Conclusion

If free will doesn’t exist, does that mean we have no control over our actions and that self-improvement is futile? It might seem that way. If my consciousness is just a byproduct of neural and environmental factors, is there any point in trying to change?


Should I Give Up?

Despite the percieved lack of free will, I believe giving up is never the answer. Even if I am a product of genetic and environmental determinants, I represent the result of countless generations of evolutionary processes. My existence serves a purpose in the context of evolution: to pass on my genetic material and optimise for personal happiness as there exists no such thing as group selection and there is no apparent point in trying to do altruistic good deeds from the prespective of biology.

Even if free will is an illusion, the goal remains clear: live, be happy, and pass on my genes. In this sense, I am no different from any other creature driven by evolutionary forces.


Ignorance is Bliss

Given the complexities of free will and determinism, I’ve chosen a simple, perhaps childish motto,ignorance is bliss. Worrying about whether my actions are truly free won’t change the way I live my life. My decisions are guided by past experiences, hormones, and genetic predispositions. Accepting this reality allows me to focus on living within the parameters set by my biology and environment.


The Plasticity of the Brain

While the brain is highly plastic and changes throughout a lifetime, the fundamental pillars — our instincts, impulses, and emotional drivers — remain constant. This makes the study of evolutionary behavior valuable, as it offers generalized insights applicable to all humans.

For those who want to embrace the primal voilent aspects of human nature, aggression, anger, and some of the mellow ones like, love, care and reciprocative altruism , these are some of the traits worth striving for. Humans are, after all, kind of a mix between a tournament species and a pair bonding species — where competition for mates and resources is intrinsic to our evolutionary success along with the need for compainionship and kinship.

palls